[Standards-JIG] Re: Fwd: RFC 3994 on Indication of Message Composition for Instant Messaging

[Cedric Vivier]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Cedric Vivier wrote:
| Peter Saint-Andre wrote:
| |>Subject: RFC 3994 on Indication of Message Composition for Instant
| Messaging
|
| Does it mean JEP-0022 (Message Event) and JEP-0085 (Chat States
| Notification) will soon be deprecated?
|

I've just read the RFC and I am disappointed... at first I was thinking
this RFC 3994 would be a improved and 'honored' version of Chat States
Notification JEP, but actually it is a very simple active/idle system
without any of more precise states as pause, opening, closing (though
these terms are used in '2. Terminology and Conventions').

Furthermore I don't understand the goal of the <refresh/> element, Chat
States is working great without this, and this is something which IMHO
complexify client implementations for nothing (or so).

I hope this will be revised in some other version :)

- --cedricv
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.6 (GNU/Linux)

iQEVAwUBQhB9eS7DGrBzh2VQAQK+nQf/aAiFWVs/tVkPgqzvWP3FkjWReFqiWtna
x9//YlcCthAsblx/5AVB98mTiY9t9R/dEB4i1pGy2y5DVRqdDLr5aaVgc0uMV85h
Jv/so2febNleklSwFx7IXOC0/e+3FIK+vHcsZPjGJ/ZEraoB8iGU/7YQZp9neZKS
KmbOS/Jo58Pbt2EPydGtLfdczb+kXmI5pKVssti8pwta02HZRwDuqdlpJcRdg5i1
FPRFiZXxRKNCLUoReHKs+qRXtpQE88s2GYN7HaRUXUmIGjpdMNXX/PSiD71PMNwd
Ba8K/HrVughkVqrcEuPboQItSODDQStEipDRzLm2OLHxQXpmE7BvCg==
=rtA0
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----