[Standards-JIG] Re: Re: UPDATED: JEP-0163 (Personal Eventing via Pubsub)

[Remko Troncon]

> That's another simplifying assumption if you ask me, and it
> seems to be appropriate.

IMO, it should be MUST. I want to be certain that PEP in its simplest
form (i.e. without custom configuration) behaves the same everywhere,
and the default access model is probably the most important part.

> Another point that came up at the interop event was creating a node on
> first publish (similar to "create room on join if it doesn't already
> exist" in multi-use chat). This is OK if we have an acceptable default
> access model (I vote for "presence"), then if you want some other access
> model then ask for it via node creation. So if there are no objections I
> will work that into the next version of the spec.

Can this also be a 'the server MUST create a node upon first publish if
it the node does not exist yet?'. Because otherwise there's no way to
know for a simple client (that does not support node customizations)
whether or not he has to create his nodes. And node creation is a
tedious job from the client's point of view.

cheers,
Remko