[Standards] Question about MUC XEP-0045 concerning full and semi anonymous rooms

[Peter Saint-Andre]

On Thu, Oct 11, 2007 at 11:54:02AM +0200, Romain Vincens wrote:

> >Yes, of course the presence is always broadcasted to every members,
> >and the full JID is not present in the packet, otherwise how could an
> >occupant of the chat know who are in the room ?
> 
> Precisely if we want to have a MUC room which is _really_ semi- 
> anonymous: now one knows who is in the room, except moderators. The  
> purpose is to have some kind of waiting room (like at the doctor)  
> where chatting is disabled. The doctor is the only occupant to know  
> who is in the room.
> 
> >Section 7.1.3 "The service MUST also send presence from the new
> >occupant's room JID to the full JIDs of all the occupants (including
> >the new occupant)", it seems clear enough for me.
> 
> Fair enough

If there is confusion, it is the fault of the spec author.

I'll try to clear this up a bit more in the text.

Peter

-- 
Peter Saint-Andre
https://stpeter.im/