[Standards] XEP-0115 redux

Alexander Gnauck gnauck at ag-software.de
Fri Jan 18 05:02:08 CST 2008


Peter Saint-Andre schrieb:
>> I'm fine with either a best-practices form of iq:version queries, or 
>> just putting the n and v attributes (and optionally 'os') into caps.  
>> Since we now have a XEP-0115 draft with n/v/os, let's go with that 
>> unless anyone has a real major objection?
> 
> We'll run it up the flagpole and see who salutes. :)
> 
> Since we already have 'v' and Kevin proposed 'n', I figure let's add 
> 'os' and we'll have everything you can find in XEP-0092...

i still think this information does not belong to caps only because some 
users would like to see the os which I am running.

We also have jabber:iq:time, which is more useful for me than the os 
when talking to people in other timezones. And there is many other stuff 
which people want to render on their roster.

I agree with Joe here, don't break a good protocol because of some info 
which is useful for some people only. I vote for a new XEP where we can 
add all this information people want.

And Peter stats show us that the additional info in each presence need 
more bytes than the iq floods in long lived sessions.

Alex



More information about the Standards mailing list