Hi,

On Mon, Jul 15, 2024, at 22:42, Tim Henkes wrote:

I think responses in MUC would only cause chaos, maybe the XEP should just forbid that.
Actions in MUC should be good though, I want actions to work in MUCs. Voting should be fine too as long as everybody is aware that the votes are not anonymous. Why do you think this XEP might not be right for voting?

I didnt think it through what would actually be necessary for a good voting functionality. I just wanted to know if it was considered by the XEP.

I think voting is a think that deservs its own XEP and should not be an afterthought.

For voting i think much more rules would be needed, like for example not accepting 2 votes from the same person, or interpet a different vote from the same person as correction, etc.

Regards

Philipp