XEP-0045 'roomsecret' field definition
Hi all, The 'roomconfig_roomsecret' data form field definition is not consistent. In XEP-0045, examples 157 and 165 use 'text-private'. The registry submission in paragraph 16.5.3 uses 'text-single'. The registry itself (https://xmpp.org/registrar/formtypes.html) uses 'text-private'. To me, this seems to boil down to a mistake in paragraph 16.5.3, which should be corrected to 'text-private'. Given that the XEP is Stable, can we bluntly do that? Kind regards, Guus
On 30/09/2025 10.36, Guus der Kinderen wrote:
Hi all,
The 'roomconfig_roomsecret' data form field definition is not consistent.
In XEP-0045, examples 157 and 165 use 'text-private'. The registry submission in paragraph 16.5.3 uses 'text-single'.
The registry itself (https://xmpp.org/registrar/formtypes.html <https:// xmpp.org/registrar/formtypes.html>) uses 'text-private'.
To me, this seems to boil down to a mistake in paragraph 16.5.3, which should be corrected to 'text-private'. Given that the XEP is Stable, can we bluntly do that?
Given that the registry itself lists the correct type of text-private, it just seems to be an mistake in the XEP's registry submission listing that we should fix regardless of the XEPs state. - Flow
participants (2)
-
Florian Schmaus -
Guus der Kinderen