[Council] final voting reminder!

Jack Moffitt jack at chesspark.com
Sat Oct 25 00:47:50 CDT 2008


>>  XEP-0206,
>
> Reading through BOSH I noticed other stuff that needs a bit of work -
> nothing major, just oddities.
>
> body MUST be empty - good.
> server SHOULD ignore - fine.
> server MAY send - wrong - this is not truly optional behaviour.
>
> "[...] SHOULD ignore it. Some implementation are known to send that stanza
> when [...]" is prefereable, to avoid the implication that sending the stanza
> is actually okay.
>
> Assuming you fix this, I'm +1, but as things stand that's a -1.

I also dislike the "server MAY send" language, but I'd have to go back
and look and see if that was discussed in our bosh meeting.

jack.


More information about the Council mailing list