[Council] XEP-198 1.2 proxy vote

Nathan Fritz nathanfritz at gmail.com
Wed Mar 2 10:45:48 CST 2011

In section 5 "In addition, this allows entities to establish
definitively which stanzas require resending and which do not,
eliminating replay issues." seems to be a bit over-promising. It will,
in fact, not prevent all replay depending on the frequency of the ack.
I suppose it is up for interpretation.

Regardless, I believe that to be a very minor nitpick that does not
affect the spec itself.

+1 on 198 1.2 (in fact a lack of veto)

-Nathan Fritz

More information about the Council mailing list