[Members] technical review team

Nathan Fritz nathanfritz at gmail.com
Tue Oct 20 11:42:15 CDT 2009


> I think it would be good to clarify what weight such reviews are to have in
> the council considerations.
>
> Given the reference to IETF team/directorate reviews, I would assume that
> such reviews would be considered as comments from the individual reviewer,
> not given any special weight due to the reviewer being a member of the
> technical review team.
>
> In particular, the technical review team is not an approval authority.  A
> positive technical review, while desirable, is not required for
> acceptance/advancement of a technical specification by the council.
>
> -- Kurt
>

Right, I don't think the review team would have any authority.

-Nathan Fritz


More information about the Members mailing list