[Members] XMPP Standards Foundation on Facebook

jehan at zemarmot.net jehan at zemarmot.net
Thu Dec 16 07:27:57 CST 2010


On Thu, 16 Dec 2010 06:10:59 -0700, Peter Saint-Andre
<stpeter at stpeter.im> wrote:
> On 12/16/10 5:04 AM, Remko Tronçon wrote:
>>> And to finish, as for someone who don't know much about these services,
>>> I would really like to hear about the added values of these services.
>>
>> Maybe you should try these services for a while, I don't think it's
>> something someone can explain to you. I would personally recommend to
>> try all new services for a while, even if you don't agree with the
>> philosophies. How else can we build open alternatives if we don't
>> understand the closed ones? You can always unsubscribe after trying it
>> (like Peter did with LinkedIn and Facebook)
> 
> I think that these services are great for most people. I just happen to
> be anti-social. :)
> 

Probably me too. And also I don't see XMPP as an alternative to these
kind of "social services". Hence I am personally not trying to build an
open alternative to these.

Plus, I may not have ever used these kind of services, but I saw people
use them from time to time and other times people told me what they do
on it, and I really never felt this was any kind of interesting (at
least for myself).

>> That said, I think we all agree on this thread. I'm sure Ludovic only
>> meant to do good for the XSF by creating the facebook page, I think
>> it's pretty clear that we don't want an 'official' facebook XSF page
>> (whatever that means), so let's just not call it an 'official' page.
> 
> Agreed on all points.
> 
> Peter

Agreed also. And to make it clear, I was never reproaching anything to
Ludovic. I don't think this is a problem to propose this kind of thing
as long as we can discuss this.
Nevertheless the only thing I was a little "shocked" was that the
badges appeared, as a one-sided decision, on the website while members
were discussing the topic on the member list (moreover mainly discussing
"against it"), and I don't think this was Ludovic who did this. And I
don't care who anyway, the goal is not to blame anyone.
Bye.

Jehan


More information about the Members mailing list