[Members] New slogan...

David Banes dbanes at cleartext.com
Sun Dec 18 10:22:02 UTC 2011


On 17/12/2011, at 4:27 PM, Matthew Wild wrote:

> On 17 December 2011 09:28, David Banes <dbanes at cleartext.com> wrote:
>> I'm using this when talking about XMPP IM.
>> 
>> 'If it's not federated, it's not XMPP'.
>> 
> 
> Except it is...

I agree of course it is :)

> 
> Are you going to say that every private non-federated XMPP server
> isn't XMPP? XMPP is just a protocol.
> 

Of course not.

> I completely understand your sentiment, I just think there needs to be
> a better way to express it :)
> 

I think we all realise that I'm aiming at the Facebook's and Microsofts of the world who appear to be happy to use the protocol and benefit from the hard work of the community but aren't 'giving back' by playing the same game we all are, which is that it's widely accepted that XMPP deployments for end users are federated. 

The tag line is just meant to get people asking what I'm talking about but I agree it's less than ideal. 

> Regards,
> Matthew

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Instant Messaging Filtering & Archiving by Cleartext - http://www.cleartext.com/im
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


More information about the Members mailing list