[Standards-JIG] Corrections to JEP-0045 text

Scott Deboy sdeboy at comotivsystems.com
Fri Dec 17 22:56:57 UTC 2004


I've been reading through JEP-0045 and noticed a couple of issues with the text:

5.2.2: http://www.jabber.org/jeps/jep-0045.html#affil-change
The table describes state transitions for the Admin affiliation.

In 5.2.1, there is a note at the end of the section that states 'An admin or owner MUST NOT be able to revoke moderation privileges from another admin or owner.'  

Does this mean that a user with admin affiliation cannot revoke another user's admin affiliation?  If so, the transitions in the Admin row should remove 'admin' from each of the transitions.  

As a minor point, I think it would be helpful to describe in the admin transitions row that prior to a transition from admin to outcast, the user must first transition to 'none' or 'member' - same for owner.

6.8: http://www.jabber.org/jeps/jep-0045.html#continue
Example 50:
The message stanzas contain two 'from' attributes.  The second attribute should be 'to'.

Scott



More information about the Standards mailing list