11 May
2026
11 May
'26
4:36 p.m.
On Mon, 11 May 2026 at 16:13, Marvin W. <xmpp(a)larma.de> wrote:
If you want to say "hey people, I'm trying to
come up with something, but
I don't know how and what exactly, let's work on this document under XSF
IPR policy", you don't need to make it Experimental. You can just say this
and avoid any doubts on whether your XEP is encouraged for Experimental
implementations or not. And if you think we need a venue that is explicitly
under XSF IPR policy but not ready for experimental implementations yet,
then talk to the board.
But... that *is* Experimental... Experimental doesn't mandate
implementation, it merely encourages it. And you can implement this, not
that it's required, and I have, not that I had to. Experimental doesn't
even require implementable.
The Process we have literally doesn't have a stage before Submission. So
you're asking, as a Council member, that I should NOT follow our process as
documented in XEP-0001?
Dave.