On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 at 20:46, Philipp Hörist <philipp@hoerist.com> wrote:
Hi
And with that, I'm now confused again. Easy to do.
All known MUCs? Presumably this is all MUCs that Gajim has ever joined, or is it all MUCs it's ever discovered via disco, MUC search services, etc?
Bookmarks are a way in XMPP for clients to hold a list of group chats it knows and wants to remember. What "knowing" means, is up to the clients. Usually this means, a group chat the user was a part of at least once.
Right, I think bookmarks are a way for *users* to hold a list of chats they want to remember. My client shows them all, joined or not, in the chat roster. So to handle that, I'd now need to bookmark bookmarks...
Such a concept i would assume is als present on other chat networks.
If you login to a gateway for Matrix, you expect that your "Known Group Chat List" now also knows all the known Matrix Chats from your Matrix account.
Ah, yes, and I agree that a client should be able to discover them easily. But I think that ramming them all into bookmarks is not the right way. What you want is either: * Your client gets told, somehow, about the place to disco for more rooms. * Your client gets told, somehow, about the place to issue a XEP-055 search for more rooms. * Your server gets told that, for you, the XEP-0055 room search should also search these other places. Of these, I think I like the last one best.
The most obvious way for a gateway to sync that info would be to add them to your bookmarks. (for contacts we have the roster where the same mechanism exists)
Now you have a bunch of matrix rooms in your bookmark list, but no name for them, and no attribute for the server to put it.
I think if the data does not fit, that suggests it's the wrong data. Dave.