Thanks everyone for their reasoned comments and feedback. I'll remove the reference to origin-id. On 2025/01/13 11:34, Daniel Gultsch wrote:
Hi JC and others,
council feels strongly that this document should get rid of its use of orgin-id and instead use the message@id for 1:1 chats.¹
This is in line with a general consensus I feel in the community that we should get rid of origin-ids everywhere except for the niche purpose of tracking reflections in MUCs that do not announce #stable_id
This means no XEP should refer to or make use of origin-id. There are obviously other XEPs that need to be modified including of course XEP-0359 itself.
The jury is still out on whether stanza-ids or message@id should be used for retractions in MUCs. Community feel free to discuss this in the comments.
Personally I’m leaning towards stanza-ids (meaning leave that part as is) which would be in line with other relatively modern XEPs like reactions or displayed markers.
cheers Daniel
P.S.: Since most clients set message@id==origin-id when sending getting rid of origin-ids in this document should just work(tm) in practice and not require a NS bump or anything. _______________________________________________ Standards mailing list --standards@xmpp.org To unsubscribe send an email tostandards-leave@xmpp.org