I have attached a screenshot to this message. The screenshot is of Rivista which reads data posted at Movim. https://mov.im/node/pubsub.movim.eu/gamingopensource/cast-out-the-heretic-ga... Observed node ------------- xmpp:comments.movim.eu?;node=urn:xmpp:microblog:0:comments/cast-out-the-heretic-gamingopensource-Of3VT1 Observed items -------------- yvelia Mon, 25 Jul 2022 06:20:15 GMT Also flathub exists, if one doesn't mind flatpaks. kris Fri, 11 Feb 2022 20:40:36 GMT https://freegamedev.net and https://libregaming.org are nice open-source game communities. kris Fri, 11 Feb 2022 20:39:24 GMT ⼠Notice that Kris has, in fact, posted a couple of comments, yet he probably had an intentention to post a single comment, and add a reaction to the post to which a comment was made. Observed items -------------- xmpp:comments.movim.eu?;node=urn:xmpp:microblog:0:comments/cast-out-the-heretic-gamingopensource-Of3VT1;item=5c9bbf68-bc1a-41f7-b484-bed8a922d9eb xmpp:comments.movim.eu?;node=urn:xmpp:microblog:0:comments/cast-out-the-heretic-gamingopensource-Of3VT1;item=26726837-c3b1-4dee-9643-3042c0b54b8c Therefore, reactions managed within Atom Syndication Format entries, would also reduce the number of items per node, which would save storage and bandwidth. Kind regards, Schimon On Thu, 5 Sep 2024 08:28:27 +0300 Schimon Jehudah <sch@fedora.email> wrote:
Good day!
I am working on Rivista[1], which is a journal publisher for XMPP.
I test instances of Libervia and Movim against Rivista.
Most of the tests are conducted against the official instance of Movim.
The matter of this message is concerning to Adding a Comment[2] (clause 3.2 to XEP-0277).
I have noticed that "reactions" are manifested exactly the same as comments, inside element title.
The couple of indications that a comment is a reaction are:
1) Element title has a single character; or 2) The character or character combination is included in the range of characters that are dedicated for reactions.
I would suggest to use a classifier.
1) Use element title as a classifier of post type, either a comment or a reaction, and use element summary as a handler for the comment itself; or
2) Use element category (e.g. xmpp:comment and xmpp:reaction); or
3) Utilize "Extension Elements" (clause 6.4 to RFC 4287).
I think that solution #3 would be the ideal solution.
Current ------- <entry xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom'> <author> <name>Juliet Capulet</name> <uri>xmpp:juliet@capulet.lit</uri> </author> <title type='text'>She is so pretty!</title> <published>2008-05-08T18:39:02Z</published> </entry>
Title as an indicator --------------------- <entry xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom'> <author> <name>Juliet Capulet</name> <uri>xmpp:juliet@capulet.lit</uri> </author> <title type='text'>comment</title> <summary type='text'>She is so pretty!</summary> <published>2008-05-08T18:39:02Z</published> </entry>
Category as an indicator ------------------------ <entry xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom'> <author> <name>Juliet Capulet</name> <uri>xmpp:juliet@capulet.lit</uri> </author> <title type='text'>She is so pretty!</title> <category term='xmpp:comment'/> <published>2008-05-08T18:39:02Z</published> </entry>
A dedicated extension --------------------- <feed xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:reactions="http://xmpp.org/2024/reactions">
For comments:
<!-- Custom Reactions Extension --> <entry xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom'> <author> <name>Juliet Capulet</name> <uri>xmpp:juliet@capulet.lit</uri> </author> <title type='text'>She is so pretty!</title> <reactions:reaction type="đĄď¸"/> <reactions:reaction type="đď¸"/> <published>2008-05-08T18:39:02Z</published> </entry>
For posts:
<!-- Custom Reactions Extension --> <reactions:reaction type="âď¸" count="10"/> <reactions:reaction type="đĄď¸" count="2"/> <reactions:reaction type="đď¸" count="5"/>
Kind regards, Schimon
[1]: https://git.xmpp-it.net/sch/Rivista [2]: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0277.html#comment_add _______________________________________________ Standards mailing list -- standards@xmpp.org To unsubscribe send an email to standards-leave@xmpp.org
