[Foundation] membership, money, and meritocracy

Peter G. Millard me at pgmillard.com
Sat Apr 5 09:46:44 CST 2003


----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Ralph Meijer" <jabberfoundation at ralphm.ik.nu>
> On Sat, Apr 05, 2003 at 02:10:25AM +0200, johannes.wagener at gmx.net wrote:
> > I hope you agree that the people in the group that writes jabber related
code are the
> > same people that bring in JEP (just because why should some non jabber
developer
> > have the idea to make a JEP???)... and in addition to that they are the
people that have
> > the neccessary experience in jabber to be able to judge a JEP.
> >
> > I am sorry, that the development of my client is not as fast as the one
of others. That is
> > because of my lag of time of course... I am still implementing my todo
list that holds
> > mainly the current existing JEPs. Whatever I think I have the skills to
judge a JEP.
> > Thus I think esspecially the people that write jabber related code
should have a free
> > oportunity to judge about other JEPs. And this is the JSF i think.
> As it stands now, the JSF membership does NOT decide on the acceptance of
JEPs.
> This is done by the Jabber Council. The Standards JIG is the place to
discuss
> protocols, but this list is not for JSF members only. Everyone can voice
his
> opinion on the various proposals, and everyone's voice carries the same
weight
> there, member or non-member.
>
> Changing the JSF structure so that the members of the JSF all belong to
teams,
> doesn't change this, at all.

Exactly - The current state of affairs means that ANYONE that participates
in the Jabber Community is able to 'voice' their opinions on JEP's via the
standards-jig mailing list. This is (and should continue to be) a completely
public list which anyone can join. Being a member of the JSF right now has
absolutely NO bearing on what JEP's get passed. Anyone in the community can
author a JEP. Anyone can join the mailing list to participate in discussions
about JEPs. Only the Council "passes" JEPs so that they become "standard"
protocols.

pgm.




More information about the Members mailing list