[Members] proposal to join the Open Invention Network

Winfried Tilanus winfried at tilanus.com
Thu Jan 21 14:02:01 UTC 2016


On 01/20/2016 05:17 PM, Peter Saint-Andre wrote:

Hi,

> Yes, sorry, I should have mentioned that. I did have a conversation with
> OIN's European representative about the XSF joining as well as companies
> and projects within the XMPP community joining. They would
> enthusiastically welcome both.

This is an important step and I would welcome joining the OIN very much.
It would give protection against patent claims far beyond anything we
have now. (Note that patent-pools work a bit like the nuclear missiles
during the cold war: it is a treat that if you fire on us, we will react
decisively, deliberately taking the risk of mutual destruction, a total
collapse of the patent system in this case. Joining a patent pool is
like joining the NATO, Warsaw Pact or whatever...)

But as far as I understand the legal construction of the OIN, the
members individually can say: XMPP is not Linux, so we don't have the
obligation to pull the trigger when XMPP is under attack. I would love
to see some better guarantee that the members of the OIN would indeed
react when XMPP is under attack: XMPP is, as far as I can see, further
away from the Linux ecosystem then anything else they protect.

Winfried


More information about the Members mailing list