[Members] discuss.xmpp.org - Let's establish a great discussion venue for XMPP

Florian Schmaus flo at geekplace.eu
Tue Feb 14 09:58:02 UTC 2017

On 13.02.2017 12:03, Goffi wrote:
> Le samedi 11 février 2017, 22:08:29 CET Florian Schmaus a écrit :
>> Hi everyone,
>> [...]
>> I hereby propose that we fade out mail.jabber.org in favour of a
>> self-hosted Discourse [1] instance at discuss.xmpp.org. Discourse is an
>> open source forum that *can be used just like a traditional mailing
>> list* (I ♥ mailing lists). It is easy to self-host, and I volunteer to
>> setup that instance and maintain it (I already maintain two Discourse
>> installations). Furthermore, it provides the required features to
>> organize the valuable information, e.g. we could tag discussion threads.
>> Want to find all discussions about XEP-0198? Just click on the tag!
>> [...]
>> the future of XMPP.
>> - Florian
>> 1: discourse.org
> Hello Florian,
> while I'm not against moving to something else (as long as we can still use 
> standard@ as a mailing list), I find it really sad that in 2017 we are willing 
> to move main XSF discussion platforms to something centralised (even it's free 
> software), and most importantly not based on XMPP, it's like confessing a 
> failure of all the work done.
> We have not (yet) a trendy and shiny platform like discourse that's true, but 
> we have everything we need to do one, and we can do gateway to email network 
> to keep the current mainly list behaviour.
> We could use PubSub or normal messages with a webview for now, and move to MIX 
> in the future. Actually we already have projects of doing a XMPP based mailing 
> list platform.
> That would be a neat demonstration to newcomers of what we can do with XMPP.
> If we are not in a rush, I'm pretty sure we can do something nice in a couple 
> of months, and I would be happy to help with that (it is a project I'm willing 
> to do for long anyway).

If you can commit on creating a mailing list replacement with similar
functionality as Discourse (tags, nice web interface, mobile ready, sane
mail threading, …) within the next 6 months, then please do so.

But I doubt that this is feasible, nor within our abilities.

On the other hand: Why start from scratch when you could simply add
"XMPP support" to Discourse. That way, you would piggyback on the
massive user base and traction Discourse already has, and make XMPP
known to a wider audience. You could start with features like XMPP
notifications for new posts on subscribed Discourse threads, and
exposing threads via MIX. It think that would be awesome.

Starting yet another forum/mailing list software from scratch just
because there is none based on XMPP doesn't sound like something worth
putting effort in.

- Florian

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: signature.asc
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 610 bytes
Desc: OpenPGP digital signature
URL: <http://mail.jabber.org/pipermail/members/attachments/20170214/5f072146/attachment.sig>

More information about the Members mailing list