[Standards] XEP 313 error handling

Kurt Zeilenga kurt.zeilenga at isode.com
Wed Dec 3 21:11:21 UTC 2014


How does the server, after it has responded to the IQ with a type=result stanza, communicate errors in processing the query to the client that might subsequently occur.   What if the server is unable to send any subsequent stanzas associated with the query?  Is the server expected to hold off sending the IQ response until it is reasonable assured that no subsequent errors will occur?  That is, to the time in which has compiled all the stanzas to sends to the client and is ready to put them to XMPP stream?

It seems to me that the IQ response really should come last so that the server is able to indicate to the client whether or not is has successfully completed the request or failed.   If sent last, then there’s really no need for a separate <fin/>.

If the IQ response is not last, there there really needs to be some method for the server to indicate that it’s not able to provide further results.

Anyways, I’ve implemented this, and for now we hold back the IQ response until we get the data from our internal archives and are otherwise ready to respond to the query.   This ensures that if we are generally able to provide an error response if any error happens to occur during the processing of the query.

— Kurt




More information about the Standards mailing list