This appears to be a transcript of an interview with the person that has
started the development on XMTP. The origin of the name is discussed, as
being a combination of SMTP and XMTP.
https://web3galaxybrain.com/episode/XMTP-with-Matt-Galligan
I personally don't like the similarities of the naming (even in English
pronunciation, the letters T and P are similar), but my first impression is
not that it is malicious. It is going to be very, very confusing if this
ever takes off. Given that there apparently is a source of investment, it
could be argued that it already has taken off.
From a quick scan, the project seems to be in ernest development for a
reasonable amount of months (but not years) now. The longer that it is
active (and the longer that the name XMTP is cemented in as their identity)
the less likely it will be that they can be convinced that the similarities
between the names are going to hurt both technologies more than that it is
beneficial to them.
If we do want to try and convince them to consider a name change, then I
suggest we do so in the spirit of them too benefitting from a strong,
not-to-be-confused-with-that-other-protocol identity, rather than from a
get-off-my-lawn argument.
Op ma 21 jul 2025 10:48 schreef Badri Sunderarajan <badrihippo(a)disroot.org>rg>:
I have been wondering about this too.
Most of the website including the documentation seemed LLM-generated to
me and there are very few technical specifications to be found. That
made me wonder whether it is worth bothering with it at all. But since
it's supported by a well-funded company, seems to have known customers
including Coinbase, and is actively looking for more funding, perhaps
it's better to raise our voices regarding the name.
This coverage by Fortune mentions "other decentralised messaging
protocols" including Matrix, but makes no mention of XMPP:
https://fortune.com/crypto/2025/07/17/xmtp-ephemera-messaging-protocol-unio…
I wonder if the authors of that article were just confused or didn't
know that XMPP existed in the first place.
Best,
Badri